Fanny Hensel, April

Resources for
Music 15200

Home page
Assignments
Resources
Species
guidelines

Resources page

Reserve

Text review

Unit 7
Unit 8
Unit 9
Unit 10
Unit 11

Exam review

Exam 1
Final Exam

Song Analysis

General
guidelines

This page has a variety of resources for students in Larry Zbikowski's undergraduate harmony course at the University of Chicago, Winter term 2003.

Items on Regenstein Reserve

Edward Aldwell and Carl Schachter, Harmony and Voice Leading, 3rd ed. (Wordsworth, 2003) [Call number: MT50 .A446 2003]

Edward Aldwell and Carl Schachter, Harmony and Voice Leading: Workbook [Vol. 1] 3rd ed. (Wordsworth, 2003) [Call number: TBA]

Felix Salzer and Carl Schachter, Counterpoint in composition; the study of voice leading (McGraw-Hill Book Co., 1969) [Call number: MT55.S2]

Johann Joseph Fux, The study of counterpoint from Johann Joseph Fux's Gradus ad parnassum (trans. and ed. Alfred Mann, with the collaboration of John Edmunds) (W. W. Norton, 1965) [Call number: MT40.F921]

Top of page

Review questions for A&S Unit 7

  1. What does it mean to "expand" a harmony? Does the expansion introduce more notes, or does it refer to spreading the harmony out over time?
  2. How can the first inversion of tonic combine with root-position tonic and dominant to create an arpeggiation of tonic?
  3. What interval does the bass of the root position leading-tone harmony make with the fifth of the chord? How would this interval be treated in, say, second-species counterpoint? Given that the bass is a very prominent voice in common-practice style, what advantage is there to using a first inversion leading-tone harmony instead of a root position?
  4. How can first inversion harmonies be used to create a better interaction between harmony and rhythm?
Top of page

Review questions for A&S Unit 8

  1. Why are inversions of the dominant-seventh harmony a more effective way to move to the tonic than V6 or vii6?
  2. Where does the bass of a first-inversion dominant-seventh harmony more or less have to go? What about the bass of a third-inversion dominant seventh? Does the bass of a second-inversion dominant seventh have similar pronounced tendencies?
  3. Look over examples 8-10 through 8-12. In the majority of these exercises, how are the bass notes moving? By step or by leap?
  4. What does it mean for tonic to be a neighboring or passing chord?
Top of page

Review questions for A&S Unit 9

  1. What is an "intermediate harmony?" Since "intermediate" generally means "standing between," to what is this harmony intermediate?
  2. What scale steps can be supported by the intermediate harmonies discussed in this chapter? (For example, we already know that tonic can support 1, 3, or 5.)
    Note that A&S speak of the juxtaposition of the "key-defining interval" (remember what that is?) through a use of ii and V at a cadence. In practical terms, this means that a cadence may involve not simply V to I, but may include a preparatory ii or IV as well as part of the entire cadential gesture.
  3. Why could moving from IV to V cause voice-leading problems?
  4. What do A&S mean with their distinction between a harmonic connection (between ii and V, for instance) and a melodic connection (between IV and V, or between I and ii)?
  5. What are the advantages of using ii6 (compared with root-position ii)?
  6. How can ii or IV facilitate motion to the dissonant harmony V7?
  7. Scan the second main section of the chapter, titled "IV and ii in Contrapuntal Progressions." In general, what kind of things can happen to bass lines once these harmonies have been introduced?
    Note their discussion of the 5-6 technique on pp. 137-38. The example from Mozart is not particularly compelling (there are simpler examples of this technique in the repertoire) but it does set up A&S’s next point, which involves following IV with ii (both in root position).
  8. How should meter and bass coordinate?

Top of page

Review questions for A&S Unit 10

  1. Why do A&S analyze the A-D-F#-A (reading up from the bass) in m. 7 of their example 10-1 on p. 146 as a dominant chord in D major?
  2. What is the best strategy for doublings in the cadential 6-4? What note should you avoid doubling?
  3. Where does the cadential 6-4 generally fall in the measure, and why?
  4. Just what is a "back-relating dominant"?

Top of page

Review questions for A&S Unit 11

  1. Aldwell and Schachter open with this sentence: "To study harmony and voice leading is to study the expansion of simple patterns into more complex and differentiated ones, creating the possibility for new kinds of tonal motion and new tonal goals." Now what is this supposed to mean? How does it relate to bass arpeggiations (such as I-vi-IV, or I-vi-ii6)?
  2. How does progression by "falling fifth" relate to the use of vi?
  3. What (or who, or where) is a Phrygian cadence? Is the food good there? And what harmonies would be on the menu?
  4. Is it possible to move directly from vi to V? What are the voice-leading problems that might be entailed.?
  5. How can vi and IV6 coordinate in moving to V?

Top of page

Review materials for Exam 1 (2/7/01)

Harmony and voice leading

You are responsible for the material presented in class and in the A&S text through Unit 11. Know in particular the following:

  • the correct use of the various inversions of the dominant seventh
  • the most typical use of the supertonic and subdominant harmonies, in both major and minor
  • the relationship between circle-of-fifth progressions and motion toward the dominant (especially the vi-ii-V progression in major)
  • the cadential six-four, and the voice leading associated with it
  • the voice leading paradigms introduced thus far; this includes typical outer-voice patterns and more specific techniques such as the voice exchange and parallel tenths or sixths in the outer voices
  • the two basic syntactic procedures identified in the A&S text—that is, the process of establishing tonic and the process of leading toward the dominant
  • the way the supertonic can be chromatically inflected to create a stronger push toward the dominant (creating what we called a "V of V")
  • the way vi and IV6 are used

Formal structure

You should review the basic approach to form presented thus far. This includes

  • the use of tonic and dominant to articulate important formal junctures; remember that this means not only that these harmonies appear at important formal junctures, but that these appearances are carefully staged through various syntactic techniques (techniques related to both harmony and voice leading)
  • antecedent-consequent structure, from both a melodic and harmonic viewpoint
  • the distinctions between half and full (or perfect authentic) cadences
  • the use of V7 (as distinct from V or various inversions of V7) to point emphatically toward tonic

Analysis

Although the introduction to analysis has been more the topic of lectures than of readings, you should now be able to discern the analytical perspective provided by the text (revealed, for instance, when harmonies are placed in parentheses). You should also think about

  • the relationship between analysis (statements about pieces of music, made either in prose or through symbols) and theory (the systematic approach behind our use of roman numerals, figured bass, and the like)
  • relationships between outer-voice counterpoint and harmony that play into analyses
  • the goals of analytical prose
  • the difference between phrasing and the process of identifying musical phrases
  • the use of structural features typical of other domains to organize our accounts of music (that is, the importance of cross-domain mapping to musical analysis)

Top of page

Review materials for the Final Exam—Monday, March 17, 10:30-12:30

Harmonization of an unfigured bass

  • the tools and vocabulary for harmonization are those covered through Unit 14 of the book
  • I recommend that you look over past homeworks, practice harmonization on the sample basses handed out in class, and review thoroughly the techniques covered in the text
  • while your soprano line will not be held to the standard of Martin Luther’s finest, your melody will have to cover a prescribed range, and should make good (that is, both correct and interesting) counterpoint with the bass
  • the harmonization will be completed in chorale style; be sure to review especially spacing between voices and acceptable melodic intervals for individual voices.
  • you may find it useful to review basic figured bass practice, especially in the context of your keyboard exercises; facility with these helps immeasurably when harmonizing unfigured basses

Melodic completion

  • you will be given a short excerpt and will be asked to complete the melody for the excerpt in an appropriate style; in preparing for this you will find it especially useful to review the repertoire covered in class since the midterm

Analysis

  • anticipate analyzing an excerpt from an instrumental work on the exam; you will find representative examples in the A&S Workbook
  • your analysis will begin with paired roman numeral/figured bass notation; I will not be overly fussy about the figured bass, but you must notate cadential six-fours properly or suffer the consequences. . .
  • you will also be asked a few questions about the excerpt, to which you shall reply with lovingly crafted and yet concise prose

Top of page

Guidelines for Song Analysis

Study the text. Note in particular the following:

  • rhyme scheme, syllabic and metrical structure
  • internal structure of the lines
  • the play of particular words or images (sometimes reinforced by internal rhymes or particularly striking words)
  • structure of stanzas
  • the overall story told by the text

This last is perhaps the most important of all for song analysis, for it often supports correlations between music and text.

Study the music. Note in particular the following:

  • the form of the song
  • prominent musical ideas or motives
  • the relative strength of the various cadences
  • the harmonic language (especially where it seems particularly complex)
  • rhythmic structure
  • phrase structure

Study relationships between the text and the music. Note in particular the following:

  • overt connections between text and music (especially at structurally prominent points in each)
  • specifics of text setting, and in particular what words come to prominence
  • any instances of text paintinghow do the two structures relate to one another (are there instances of text painting).

Finally, try to pull all this together by developing as compelling account as possible about how text and music relate to one another, about how the text affects the interpretation of the music and how the music affects the interpretation of the text.

Top of page

Bach, Prelude from Clavier-Buechlein

For inquiries about this page, or suggestions, contact Lawrence Zbikowski, Department of Music, University of Chicago.